Sports
Dangerous Patkas & Turbans?
JOHN WALTERS, Newsweek
The most recent headgear controversy in athletics concerns a sport that may surprise you.
Basketball.
Last Saturday night at the International Basketball Federation ("FIBA") Asia Cup, India had to start its game against Japan minus two of its top players, 6-foot-11 Amrit Pal Singh and 6-foot-8 Amjyot Singh.
Minutes before the contest began in Wuhan, the largest city (population 10 million) in central China, referees had informed the two turban-clad men, who are both followers of the Sikh religion, that they were in violation of Article 4.4.2 of FIBA’s official rules, which states, “Players shall not wear equipment (objects) that may cause injury to other players.”
And so while Amrit Pal and Amjyot scrambled to doff their turbans and band their flowing manes -- many Sikhs do not cut their hair -- the game began without them. The pair checked in about two minutes later, but the distraction and discomfort led to a 23-point defeat to the Japanese -- although it must be noted that Amrit Pal scored a game-high 15 points
“We have always played in turbans, even in last year’s FIBA Asia Championship in Manila,” Amrit Pal, 23, told writer Karan Madhok, whose blog, Hoopistani, is the definitive word on Indian basketball. “But playing in the Japan game without it felt very awkward. I wear a turban in practice, too, and it was strange to not have it on during the game.”
Amrit Pal Singh, the son of a Punjabi farmer who was introduced to the sport only four years ago, has been tying a turban for just a few years. Amjyot, 22, who bears an eerie resemblance to Kobe Bryant, has worn a turban his entire life. “I find it much more comfortable playing with the turban, of course,” Amjyot told Hoopistani. “That is part of my habit.”
The issue of religious headgear and FIBA restrictions has come up before (though, not, as far as anyone knows, with nuns’ habits). In a FIBA Asia Under-18 three-on-three tournament last year, the team from Maldives forfeited when its members were prohibited from wearing hijabs. On the eve of the Asia Cup, Scott Flemming, the American head coach of the Indian national team, had secured permission for his Sikh players to wear their turbans -- or so he thought.
“I spent a long time advocating for our players the day before the Japan game and finally thought we got the OK for [them] to wear their turbans,” Flemming told Madhok. “I was then told right before the game there was a misunderstanding on what we agreed to. We had no choice. I would never make our players do anything they were uncomfortable with according to their religious practices. It was up to them.”
The idea that turbans or, for devout Muslims, hijabs may cause harm during a game to other players seems far-fetched.
Elbows, which cannot be removed, are far more potentially lethal.
Then again, Amrit Pal and Amjyot seemed to adjust to FIBA’s suppression of their religious custom with alacrity. The following night, India played host nation and prohibitive favorite China, which it had never defeated in its 78 years as a national team, and won 65-58.
India’s leading scorers in the historic upset? Amrit Pal Singh and Amjyot Singh, sans turbans, paced the team with a game-high 13 points apiece.
[Courtesy: Newsweek. Edited for sikhchic.com]
July 18, 2014
Conversation about this article
1: Sarvjit Singh (Massachusetts, USA), July 18, 2014, 12:55 PM.
Kudos to these non-Sikh reporters high-lighting this issue. Where are the Sikh Leaders on this subject? Also, a Sikh toddler asked innocently when she saw the photo of the player ... why did he agree to play with his hair down? Compromise, conformity, blending-in, survival, self preservation, etc., etc., I suppose. Is this what Guru Gobind Singh's Panth is supposed to do?
2: Sangat Singh (Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia), July 18, 2014, 6:27 PM.
Our Principal of Government College, Ludhiana in the early 1950s was a Harish Chander Katpalia. He was really witty and we always looked forward to his speeches. In his time at Government College, Lahore he was also a well-known Tennis player. One day he showed up on the court in his pyjamas. When his opponent, correctly attired, asked him why he was wearing pyjamas, his cryptic reply was: "For the same reason you are wearing longs."
3: Manpreet Singh (Wilmington, Delaware, USA), July 19, 2014, 1:51 AM.
I think fellow Sikhs like Sim Bhullar should take a stand and sport a patka or turban during his games (I know he is clean shaven) and send a strong message to the basketball and global community. Sad part is that we have become insensitive towards our own issues and people and no more stand up for ourselves ... but get immediately ready to take a stand for somebody whom we don't even know.I think it's called Hypocrisy.